Oh my. Thank you for the fabulous read you provided with your posts - I've just gone through all of them and I'm even more confused as to my own choices. Yes it is the most beloved film of all by Mr Lynch :-)
My "nominations" included:
- the 'traffic scene', a pretty safe candidate for a number one, I find pure cinematic genius in the way this scene has been filmed; perhaps it shakes me more than the 100% moving scenes like...:
- the death scene
- I love you James
- Goodnight princess (not mentioned by anyone
... turns out it's not on my list, either...)
- Questions in the World of Blue
- The Grand Finale
Other nominees:
- Pink Room
- Jeffries
- Laura and Donna about falling
- all the Chet/ Sam stuff
Finally I'm coming up with:
1. ...you stole the corn!!... it's him!... it's YOUR FATHER!!!!!
2. Log Lady's boughs of innocence and Questions in the world of blue
3. train car, Ronnette's prayer and the silent moment, don't make me do this... brr!
4. Jeffries
5. Pink Room
The final Vision of Love scene, which quite clearly is going to win the contest didn't make it for me... It's a beautiful ending but as a scene in itself it never seemed to me particularly outstanding. I'm surprised actually at how strong its win is going to be!
Honorable mention...the entire Sam and Chet stuff. I love it but no one scene stands out to me.
yes, I've got the same thing. I really really wanted to include any of those but it turned out it would hardly make it to a top ten! Yet that part of the film is great!
Bobi 1 Kenobi
B. Beware
O. Of
B. BOB