BOB1, some day you'll watch this film again and you'll love it...
But Gordon you see... thing is I've watched this film several times (four? not sure).
The scene you complimented so much (AUDITION) is a typical case of what I have against that film. It's really a very entertaining scene and all that you say about how well it is acted, and how it works on emotions - all of this I agree with and I appreciate it. So of course I like this scene.
But my feeling remains that this scene is shallow. It is supposed to impress the viewer, and it does, but it leaves me with nothing else. It doesn't carry anything which could move anything in me, evoke my thoughts or make me feel uneasy or make me look at anything from a different perspective.
Obviously not every scene always has to do it. The audition scene could be a jewel in the crown and one of the best moments of any film, on condition that the rest of the movie carries along that something which I cannot find in this scene. But in Mulholland Drive it doesn't happen.
Once Booth said that while other Lynch films are like paintings, Mulholland Drive is like a laminated postcard. I'm not sure what he meant there, perhaps only the visual side (which however I like in Mulholland). Anyway, for me that comparison works very well, too, because I fell that Mulholland Drive looks very good but lacks depth.
Some moments are more interesting for me, especially where we see Diane and her misery and frustration but unfortunately I am quite unable to identify with her character at all, so she tends to leave me unmoved.
Ah, what I like perhaps more is the Every Little Star scene, because I find that it shows in a very suggestive and creative manner how jealousy can work...yeah, that scene is very good and I'll place it on my list after all.
The Cowboy and Winkie's are very abstract scenes but for no apparent reasons they don't seem too match my sensibility or something... I appreciate them but I can't say I liek them.
Other than that it's only Silencio - which totally amazes me. It depicts illusion and losing illusions in the most powerful way I have ever seen, it is very well set in the main plotline, yet remains absolutely universal and abstract.
1. Silencio
2.
3.
4.
5. Every Little Star.
Bobi 1 Kenobi
B. Beware
O. Of
B. BOB