Eric Clapton is pretty decent.

Is he ? he is a pretty good player but he made that most anoying 'lady in red' tune didn't he ? lowest pitts of hell with him!

Eric Clapton never recorded "Lady in Red". He did record "Layla" and "Wonderful Tonight"*. Big difference.

*Also some rather depressing adult contemporary albums in the late 90s/early 00s.

EDITED to clarify.

Eric Clapton is pretty decent.

Is he ? he is a pretty good player but he made that most anoying 'lady in red' tune didn't he ? lowest pitts of hell with him!

Eric Clapton is not responsible for "Lady in Red". He is responsible for "Layla" and "Wonderful Tonight"*. Big difference.

*Also some rather depressing adult contemporary albums in the late 90s/early 00s. 

   Well, who DID make him record it then?!  I've fortunately never heard his cover of this Chris deBurgh "piece".  Actually, Wonderful Tonight is nearly in the L.I.R. league.  I think his talent has been on the decline since Layla (his pinnacle).  He works best in a group context, not solo... (okay, not a total decline. He puts out an occasional humdinger.  I guess Cream won't be doing a NEW album.  But after listening to the lackluster reunion album, I'd say no big loss)
 

I'm with you on this one Chris. I loved just about everything Clapton did in his early years. Cream is one of the most influental bands of all time. Thankfully he still puts on one hell of a live show.

Chris DeBurgh recorded Lady in Red not Eric Clapton. I dont know if Clapton covered it but its a Chris DeBurgh song.

Top 5:
Jimi Hendrix
Johnny Greenwood
Elliot Easton (the Cars)
Dave Navarro
Elvis Costello (eclipsed by his songwriting skills, but I love the stuff he does live)

Terry Kath

Rick Nielsen

Jimmy Page

Terry Kath

Boy, I remember him (not) well, B!  CTA, right?  Chicago Transit Authority.  Chicago.  He ended up marrying a girl I knew from Detroit.  She was so pretty back then.  Maybe a groupie, but who wasn't?   They moved to Malibu, had a little girl and then he shot his brains out "playing" Russian Roulette.  Who knew he played guitar? 

Later she married (and divorced) Kiefer Sutherland.  I ran into her in the baby department at Saks a couple decades ago and she filled me in on what was up with her.  Our kids were about the same age. 

Life.  What a trip!

Susan 

Saw Fountains of Wayne Sunday night, so I gots to add  Jody Porter to the list...

Some of my favourite guitarists are:

Nick Didkovsky 

Bernard Falaise (the guitarist from the band MIRIODOR)

Robert Fripp

Fred frith

Frank Zappa

The thing about EVH is that he invented a new way to play the guitar. He was a trained concert pianist (no jokes here...) and the intervals available to the piano are not traditionally achievable on the guitar. Thus, he made up his own way to get the melodies he heard in his head. Edward is one of my top three guitarists in Rock for that reason.

Who are the others, one might ask?

OK, to qualify my opinion (that and $3.50 will get you a cuppa joe), I have played guitar in bands since 1961, have been active in music since 1957 - the golden age of RNR.

The first and foremost influence on modern guitar, in the Rock'N'Roll genre is and was certainly Papa Chuck - Berry that is. He was self taught, as all innovators are, and loved the horn arrangements in big band records. His ears told him that to get that same thang on the guitar, he had to 'double-stop', which is a violin technique (listen to the startup of the slow string thing in "The Straight Story"). That was a new technique in 1955-56, and he used it to great advantage, along with Johnny (insert last name - my brain is as blank as a fart)'s brilliant train style piano playing. MOST rock guitarists pull their armament from a combination of Chuck and the older Delta Bluesmen. Including most certainly Senor Clapton and his ilk. NOT to take anything away from Eric, but he is a copyist, not an Innovator. And I know Chuck is a bum today, but he steadfastly trod the Glory Road.

The greatest guitarist between Chuck and Edward was - yup - Jimi Hendrix. Jimi was the second invention of Rock Guitar, in that he played the thing unlike any before him. He was also self-taught, though he had great road training with The Isley Brothers and such. Hendrix took the power trio to its apex, with the necessity of having to cover rhythm and lead parts at the same time. His melodic chording, or chording lead style, was unique, and has been many other guitarists' ticket, i.e: Robin Trower and SRV. they are both great technical guitarists, but not Innovators.

IMHO, ALL other guitarists are distillations of these three huge cornerposts of Rock Guitar. Yes, many had other influences, like Beck, McLaughlin, Vai, etc,. who pulled from the Jazz lexicon, but they were all derivative guitar stylists, not originals.

It remains to be seen who will be Guitar God #4.

OK, fun stuff. Discuss amongst yourselves... There will be a test.