There are times, and it pains me to say this because it's like slashing the tires of your favorite dream car, when you have to step back and admire a piece of art that managed to become something amazing despite the circumstances surrounding its creation.
Take The Exorcist. It's a movie inspired by a book about a hoax demonic possession. The book was written by a guy named Billy who, if you're ever read his interviews, is a class A village idiot. The movie was directed by another guy named Billy who was of similarly dubious mental fortitude. What resulted from their fifteen wrongs was an amazing right - a thoughtful piece that could scare people, make people think about faith and the supernatural, hell - I've even read essays which identified it as a critique of modern medicine. But all this excellence was by accident. By rights, the Exorcist should have been laughworthy.
Twin Peaks isn't like that. Lynch and Frost are certainly not Stupid Billy One and Stupid Billy Two. That having been said, it's been confirmed in countless interviews that they didn't start out with a fully-charted roadmap, and that nobody knew how far any of it was going to go. At least a considerable chunk of the plot was written as they went, with major elements changing or evolving or materializing over the run of the show. Take a look sometime at the early edits of the script for episode 29... several of the more original treatments offered completely new insights into the workings of the world of the Black Lodge. This was definitely a project set in clay, not stone.
I think I was most heartbroken, years ago, when Lynch responded to a plethora of fan questions regarding the worky bits of the mythos with something akin to "I'm not sure what it all means... but it means something, and when I figure it out I'll tell you." It's a lot more romantic, at least for me, to assume that every one of those scribbles on the Owl Cave petroglyph was placed meaningfully and intentionally... instead of "Hey, we need a cryptic ancient cave painting by Tuesday. Whip something up and make sure to include these two things in there. Have a field day with the rest."
Point being, and I think many of the readers here will resonate with me on this: what ended up coming out of the creative process on Twin Peaks was a powerful, soul-shaking thing. Reading that, it sounds over-dramatic, but having just wrapped up a rewatching of the gold box plus FWWM, I can state very honestly that regardless of how tightly or loosely it was scripted, there were TRUTHS in that series. Important questions about what it means to be human, and maybe a few about whether or not there are things out there that aren't human. The art was greater than the process, and the finished piece (left perfectly unfinished) was something magnificent. What happened to Cooper? What happened to Laura? What are these lodges? I know it sounds trite, but I think it's all in there. I think all the big questions are answered artfully. Now, the natural urge is to want more. To bang the silverware angrily on the tabletop until Mom brings out another bowl of creamed corn. But I think more could only ruin what we've already consumed. How do you add another season to something that's perfect? Season three would be an unsightly tumor on one of the leanest, meanest, sexiest existential examinations ever to cross primetime television.
I live 40 minutes from Snoqualmie Falls, and make it a regular stop. I eat lunch at Twede's Cafe (The RR) every time. Hell, I'm reading and posting to a board like this, right? I'm just as hungry for more as anyone. But I'm happy to recognize that I'd rather have that hunger as evidence of powerful art than risk being stuffed full of thinned-down filler.
So goodnight, Twin Peaks. I'm sure I'll be out to check on the waterfall, the lodge, and the cheeseburger platter sometime soon.
good topic,but not completely right.
I think fans deserve some type of continuation (tv series or film,book orsome new diary...)
The key of success of twin peaks is character of agent cooper.Every scene with him is amazing.
I think fans deserve to know:
-what did happen with Agent Cooper?
-What did happen with white lodge?
-Who is Bob?he isn't only a bad spirit,he is the "boss" of black lodge. what is with nature forces which are stronger than bob?
I think there are lot of space for investigation of twin peaks misteries.I want a new book more than tv series or film