I've been trying to deconstruct TP as an exercise in screenwriting. I was amazed at the layers and levels involved. I seem to be able to find connections to the simplest acts with equally well constructed and hidden ideas. What is with the shoes? You can trace the idea of shoes from two-armed Mike in the great smokey mountains right down to why and where the homecoming queen died. The Shoe Tree has soul!
How would TP play out if it were a Monk episode: the big reveal! 
We know that Josie shot Cooper while Senor Drool Cup shuffled along with Coop's glass of warm milk and that, in the series, Josie offered to put the coffee on to perk for Pete when Coop and Truman came to question the Martells. Did she put the Steelhead in the percolator and if so why? It seems far too petty an act to bother with. She must have known that they would only drink one sip, so why then would she do such a petty act? Simple! To cover the taste of something strongly flavored that she had slipped into the pot. What kind of mind-control, hallucenogenic, zombie-creating Bob-induced Mickey could Josie have slipped into their cuppa Joe that might explain their actions throughout the rest of the series? I need a wipe!
Why did Jacoby stay in Earring-ville Washington and worship all things Hawaiian. Well 40% of the trading company that first brought civilization to the local WERE native Hawaiians and Owayee, a portion of Oregon not near Bend, is still named for them. Sigh, the area given by Cooper to Diane as he entered TP the city was at the edge of Penn D'orville county so named 'cuz the local indiginous natives wore ponderous earrings.