this show started off good, then became amazing, then got REALLY horrible in season 3. then i stopped watching for a while because it was bad. then i tried it again on a whim about a month ago, and they pulled it together big time. i'd say it's an even more impressive recovery than the end of TP season 2. probably the best recovery i've seen. one of my favorite shows is back!

I gave up on this show after last season - I don't give a damn who the final Cylon is.

I completely agree, Nefud! We were about 3 weeks behind and we caught up the past two days!! OH MY! those two episodes with teh mutiny - absolutely wonderful TV. I was kind of hoping they would've kept the mutiny going the rest of the season to its climax but guess not. It really has turned around after htat horrible season on the plant. UGH!!!

i stuck with it through the "new caprica" stuff, but the ENDLESS "omg we are so emo about what happened on new caprica" just killed it for me. that, and one too many Rousing Adama Speeches (TM).

anyway, i'm REALLY digging the last few episodes. and most amazing of all: last week's was just chock full of exposition about the history of the cylons, how earth ties in, etc.....and it.....didn't suck! i figured the second the mysteries started clearing up, it would be awful*, but they really pulled it off. i can't wait for each episode, that hasn't happened since....doctor who's 2006 season i think?

*see also: lost, the dark tower series, the star wars prequels, twin peaks to some degree, the x-files, countless others....