I love Audrey and Laura, but from the word go, in the pilot episode, there's an innocence to her that just makes me really like her.  She's hot in a kinda hard-to-get, bitchy-teen way...but she has a purity to her I love...

I'm a Shelly man, myself!

At the risk of sounding like Lionel Richie, i'm easy... like you know what....

I dunno about her character being attractive. All I know is that LFB was really hot in her TP-days. Donna's character was kind of alluring too, I have never found her as annoying as most members here do.

I'm a Shelly man, myself!

Hell No!!!

couldn't stand donna. and, it sounds weird, but not really laura either. i loved audrey the best. and shelly was a close second. i wanted to stab myself in the head during the whole donna/james and then donna/james/maddy stuff.

She was 19 during the show but seemed like she was 35! The smoking and freckles put me off, but other than that, I am fond of Lara as an actress and thought she brought something special and sexy to the role.

As a straight woman, I don't find anything sexy about Lara as Donna.   Too wishy-washy, serious and skinny.   If i was a man (or bi!) I would go for Audrey.   Mischevious, cute and a bit dark. FWWM Donna is more attractive, I think x

My list, from hottest to least hot:

1. Shelly

2. Audrey

3. Sheryl Lee as Laura

4. Sheryl Lee as Maddy

5. Annie

6. Lucy

7. Nadine

8. Pete

9. Everyone else

10. Donna

Tut, my fella loved Shelley too, when i introduced him to TP.   I don't get it.   She's extremely pretty but the character is a bit too "gee golly gosh" for me.   I don't mind him leering all over the tv screen but i wish he could have done it cos of someone like Audrey, Laura or even Norma

My hottest guy is Dana Ashbrook as himself (OMG  how gorgeous...) but NOT as Bobby, with all the hair and the behaviour...

 I found the series overloaded with gorgeous women but not too many cute men...

Although I agree Pete is fab

I never found Donna to be attractive. A bit too . . . mousey? I'm not overly sure what word I'm looking for there. Audrey was always my pick of the mix; not in the pilot, however. Her hair didn't look right. By the end of season two Audrey looked amazing. Well, she looked amazing before the bomb went off at least . . . eek! Who knows how she ended up following that catastrophe. Second to Audrey, Annie. It certainly appears that I have the same taste in women as our man Coop.

7. Nadine

8. Pete

9. Everyone else

10. Donna

Lana > Donna

I didn't think anything of her in the pilot, but I started to notice her beauty as the show went on, mos particularly in the scene where Audrey dances in the diner and when she talks to her mother about James. She must have done something between filming the pilot and those episodes to make her beauty more noticeable.

But I'm 100% for Audrey being the most attractive Twin Peaks girl

Jenny, the perfume counter girl, is really sexy and she's never mentioned in this kind of threads... I'm sure she would've gotten 4 hearts in Battis' pimping ranking...

Jenny, the perfume counter girl, is really sexy and she's never mentioned in this kind of threads... I'm sure she would've gotten 4 hearts in Battis' pimping ranking...

 I found the series overloaded with gorgeous women but not too many cute men...

Let'sRock, for most men a woman's personality comes much much later deciding on her hotness!

Bobby, Jack Wheeler, Cooper, Gordon Cole and even James when the hair isn't styled to accentuate the forehead all qualify as hot, imo. Harry, Andy and Hawk are cute, too! (Scotty and Joey the bikers are also qualified hotness.)