This is clearly a matter of taste, but this is a forum dedicated to the work of the artist David Lynch - Inland Empire tosh? That's not my view. Is Eraserhead also tosh? I think IE is the cloest film in spirit to Eraserhead that Lynch has made and as an art film (which had the studio support of Canal+ because the French have a huge respect for 'auteur' cinema) Inland Empire is extremely refreshing.
So, I think what we have here is a conflict of taste, Lynch had a period of 'ultra cool' movie making in the 1990s but don't forget that he started from an art school background funded by the AFI and made Eraserhead and as such he is being true to himself as an artist by making films like IE. Anyway, I don't disagree that TM for my money does not appear to be a particularly positive influence on David Lynch as a creative artist lately and I said as much recently in the closing paragraph in a blog on my site http://www.online-inquirer.com/cinema/david-lynch/
Exy, I am sorry but you are wrong on every count. Firstly, this site is primarily a TP fansite. Secondly, I love DL as much as you but I reserve the right to point out stinky films, fansite or not I don’t think we have any fanboys here.
Thirdly, IE and EH could not be more different. I should say that I love EH. It is my favourite DL film. EH is a film (with a couple of short diversions) with a clear narrative, a small number of well differentiated characters and short. IE is exactly the reverse. IE is closest to MD, except that MD had a more obvious plot and characters one invested in more. Both MD and IE are set in Hollywood and focus on the plight of women (EH is about Henry’s troubled relationships). I know all about his art background etc. I’ll watch art films but any film that lasts as long IE is going to get treated like a feature film in terms of criticism and expectation and even allowing some artistic discretion I think IE is a mess.
IE had some brilliant moments – but that isn’t enough for an abusively long, fractured film. It managed to jerk us around narratively yet was still boring – quite a feat. And because one never got to stick with and observe a character (without all the double stuff) at great length one never really cared in the way one did with EH and MD and BV. Can non-IE fans even remember character names of IE characters? Even the most extreme of IE fans must concede that the editing/narrative was obscure and the film too long – or that these criticisms have merit.
I will stick with a film if I feel there is payback and that good 20min (of various parts) is not enough for me.
Furthermore, I would say to IE fans: „You realise that this film you love has killed any chance of DL making another feature?“ No, I don’t want him to make a sequel or direct a franchise. I want him to drop his tics, give me some characters I care about, add a touch of magic, humour and vision and wrap it up in under 120min. He can do that and be true to himself (MD, EH, FWWM (129min), BV). And someone hide those red drapes. Please.
I think I might be a fanboy (dives for cover).



