Ponder this (or simply consider it nonsense): Many of DL's projects begin with a premise, no matter how absurd, off-kilter or drily humorous it is, that intrigues us. Jeffrey Beaumont's Hardy Boy-like amateur sleuthing at the beginning of BV, "Who Killed Laura Palmer?" in TP, the tense relationship of Fred and Renee, and then the daily arrival of intrusive videotapes in LH, the seemingly straightforward mystery in MD of how perky Betty will help the mysterious Rita find her real identity (and also how Dan, Jacob from LOST, and all the other side characters fit into it). Even WAH seems to start off as a "wild" caricature of a delinquents-on-the-run tale before it gets more complicated. So Mr. and Mrs. Average begin watching - intrigued with the mysteries and drama, chuckling at the oddball humor, getting more and more caught up in the story, and then...subversion. BV is much more than about two innocent young people solving a mystery, TP is much more than about Laura Palmer: we have evil forces living in other dimensions, Fred apparently kills Renee, then becomes Pete? Hey, what happened to our fun, suspenseful Hollywood mystery about a couple apparently being spied on? And MD - well, don't we all feel like suckers for thinking Naomi Watts was such a sweet young thing?
But does IE have this type of mind-blowing subversion? Isn't it surreal from the start? There's not any hint of the "normal," albeit Lynchified, world suddenly twisting into something much weirder than we thought we were watching. There's a feeling of alienation from the beginning. Does this make IE less subversive (as a narrative) than those earlier works? I'm still coming to grips with what I think about IE. I'm planning to watch it again this month to analyze it more. I LIKE it, I'm not meaning to say it's inferior. I just wonder what others think of it compared to DL's earlier style as described above. As it might be a moot point if he'll make any more features, is it worth asking: What future styles of DL movies do you want to see? More in the IE style? A return to his earlier late-80s to early 2000s manner? Or something beyond? Something so new and radical that even the most hardcore Lynchian will be astonished.