Home | Register | Login | Members  

Politics > Ayaan Hirsi Ali on CONFRONTING Islam
New Topic | Post Reply
<< | 1 | >>  
1. Monday, May 15, 2006 8:26 PM
nuart Ayaan Hirsi Ali on CONFRONTING Islam


 Member Since
 12/18/2005
 Posts:7632

 View Profile
 Send PM

This is an interesting interview (in English) with the ballsy, fatwa-threatened Dutch MP, Ayaan Hirsi Ali. It was filmed in Norway in February. I know Jazz has suggested utilizing her same technique -- confronting Islam's dogma -- and I think it's a bold and wonderful idea. If you want to watch scroll down a little bit to Sunday, May 7 and it's right there to click on.

 

http://www.littlegreenfootballs.com/weblog/weblog.php


     
“Half a truth is often a great lie.”

 

Ben Franklin

 
2. Monday, May 15, 2006 8:27 PM
nuart RE: Ayaan Hirsi Ali on CONFRONTING Islam


 Member Since
 12/18/2005
 Posts:7632

 View Profile
 Send PM

My guy Christopher on my gal Ayaan. She is currently on a high profile US tour. Hope she plans to come to LA!

Fighting words
The Caged Virgin
Holland's shameful treatment of Ayaan Hirsi Ali

By Christopher Hitchens
Posted Monday, May 8, 2006, at 3:44 PM ET

Three years ago, at a conference in Sweden, I was introduced to a Dutch member of parliament named Ayaan Hirsi Ali. Originally born in Somalia, she had been a refugee in several African countries and eventually a refugee from her own family, which had decided to "give" her in marriage to a distant male relative she had never met. Thinking to escape from such confines by moving to the Netherlands, she was appalled to find that radical Islam had followed her there—or in fact preceded her there—and was proselytizing among Turkish and Moroccan and Indonesian immigrants. In ancient towns like Rotterdam and Amsterdam, where once the refugees from Catholic France and inquisitional Spain had sought refuge, and where Baruch Spinoza had been excommunicated and anathematized for his opposition to Jewish fundamentalism, there were districts where Muslim women were subjected to genital mutilation and where the Dutch police were afraid to set foot.

Entering politics to try to alert the European left to this danger, she was first elected as a deputy for the Labor Party, but after 9/11 she changed her allegiance to the Liberals. This, she explained, was because many Labor spokesmen preferred to think of immigrants as possessing "group rights." They had become so infatuated by their own "multi-culti" style that they had ignored the rights of individuals—especially women and girls—who were imprisoned within their own ghetto. (That, by the way, was precisely Spinoza's problem as well. The Dutch rabbis cursed him and condemned him in their own sectarian "court," of which the Christian authorities approved because it took care of dangerous secularism among Jews.)

At the Swedish event, Ayaan Hirsi Ali spoke calmly and rationally about the problem. I never know whether or not it's right to mention, with female public figures, the fact of arresting and hypnotizing beauty, but I notice that I seem to have done so. Shall I just say that she was a charismatic figure in Dutch politics, mainly because of the calm and reason to which I just alluded? She was the ideal choice of collaborator for the Dutch filmmaker Theo van Gogh (a distant descendant of the anguished painter) on Submission, a film about the ignored problem of enslaved and oppressed women in Holland. Ayaan Hirsi Ali wrote the screenplay and provided the movie's voice-over.

You probably remember what happened next: Van Gogh was bicycling to work one morning in 2004 in the capital city of one of Europe's most peaceful and civilized countries when he was shot down in the street and then mutilated in a ritual fashion by an Islamist fanatic. The murderer (who had expected to become a martyr but who was only wounded in the leg by the gentle Dutch cops) left a long "martyr's letter" pinned to van Gogh's corpse by an equally long knife. In it, he warned Ayaan Hirsi Ali that she was the next target, and he gave a long and detailed account of all the offenses that would condemn her to an eternity in hell. (I noticed, reading this appalling screed when it was first published, that he obsessively referred to her as "Mrs. Hirshi Ali," as if trying to make her sound like a Jew. Other references to Jews in the text were even less tasteful.)

She has had to live under police protection ever since, and when I saw her again last week in Washington, I had to notice that there were several lofty and burly Dutchmen acting in an unaffected but determined way somewhere off to the side. I would urge you all to go out and buy her new book, The Caged Virgin, which is subtitled An Emancipation Proclamation for Women and Islam. The three themes of the story are: first, her own gradual emancipation from tribalism and superstition; second, her work as a parliamentarian to call attention to the crimes being committed every day by Islamist thugs in mainland Europe; and third, the dismal silence, or worse, from many feminists and multiculturalists about this state of affairs.

Before being elected to parliament, she worked as a translator and social worker among immigrant women who are treated as sexual chattel—or as the object of "honor killings"—by their menfolk, and she has case histories that will freeze your blood. These, however, are in some ways less depressing than the excuses made by qualified liberals for their continuation. At all costs, it seems, others must be allowed "their culture" and—what is more—must be allowed the freedom not to be offended by the smallest criticism of it. If they do feel offended, their very first resort is to violence and intimidation, sometimes with the support of the embassies of foreign states. (How interesting it is that the two European states most recently attacked in this way—Holland and Denmark—should be the ones that have made the greatest effort to be welcoming to immigrants.) Considering that this book is written by a woman who was circumcised against her will at a young age and then very nearly handed over as a bargain with a stranger, it is written with quite astonishing humor and restraint.

But here is the grave and sad news. After being forced into hiding by fascist killers, Ayaan Hirsi Ali found that the Dutch government and people were slightly embarrassed to have such a prominent "Third World" spokeswoman in their midst. She was first kept as a virtual prisoner, which made it almost impossible for her to do her job as an elected representative. When she complained in the press, she was eventually found an apartment in a protected building. Then the other residents of the block filed suit and complained that her presence exposed them to risk. In spite of testimony from the Dutch police, who assured the court that the building was now one of the safest in all Holland, a court has upheld the demand from her neighbors and fellow citizens that she be evicted from her home. In these circumstances, she is considering resigning from parliament and perhaps leaving her adopted country altogether. This is not the only example that I know of a supposedly liberal society collaborating in its own destruction, but I hope at least that it will shame us all into making The Caged Virgin a best seller.


     
“Half a truth is often a great lie.”

 

Ben Franklin

 
3. Monday, May 15, 2006 8:27 PM
nuart RE: Ayaan Hirsi Ali on CONFRONTING Islam


 Member Since
 12/18/2005
 Posts:7632

 View Profile
 Send PM

I don't do airport pick-ups at Los Angeles International Airport, but I'd be happy to show you around the proverbial Southland if you get your Dutch self over to the USA, CCC! You might like it here!

 


     
“Half a truth is often a great lie.”

 

Ben Franklin

 
4. Thursday, May 11, 2006 1:29 PM
Jazz RE: Ayaan Hirsi Ali on CONFRONTING Islam


 Member Since
 12/19/2005
 Posts:2214

 View Profile
 Send PM

CCC, it's good to see that you are actually planning to do something about the amount of assholes here, have a save trip.

I wrote about Hirshi Ali before, and what I didn't write;
She is so weak in debates that it's near pathetic.
She can only talk in monologues.
I saw many debates with her, and she never once really debated .. only monologues on constant repeat.
She literally stated that her point of view is not debatable.
She is a Muslim without Allah, like most Dutch secular Humanists are actually Catholics without G*d.
They are like those people who just stopped smoking and have an over the top attitude towards smokers.
To me her performance worldwide is pretty much a huge ego trip these days.


Ayaan is doing some good work though, one should take every opportunity to pick on the Koran and the cultures it cultivated.
I personally hope a braver woman with brains will stand up with 'tha message', Ayaan was nice but we need the real deal, balls and brains.


Something else; what is so alleged about Dutch tolerance ?
The fact that 'we the people' let you whine about 'us the people' while we probably pay for your 24/7 leisure moment as well, makes a pretty strong statement don't you think ?

 

edit-ps: want to see a Jewish conspiracy ? keep up with the news on Ayaan the coming weeks :-)  


Jazz Theme

 
5. Thursday, May 11, 2006 1:35 PM
Jazz RE: Ayaan Hirsi Ali on CONFRONTING Islam


 Member Since
 12/19/2005
 Posts:2214

 View Profile
 Send PM

that's pretty decent of you
If you do find an asshole free place in the near future, let us know, the rest of the world would love to see it.

 

 

 

 


Jazz Theme

 
6. Saturday, May 13, 2006 1:02 AM
Jazz RE: Ayaan Hirsi Ali on CONFRONTING Islam


 Member Since
 12/19/2005
 Posts:2214

 View Profile
 Send PM

Television and newspapers are not my primairy news sources either, but I'm up to date anyway (being online is part of it I guess).

Today, however, I bought Trouw (newspaper) and read how Ayaan might lose her Dutch passport because of her lies when she fled to this country. Chances are that she might have to leave this country as an illegal allien in the very near future.
I'm sure this is just the start of it, "they" are after her, and will probably get her as well. 

It might help her to be even more loved with the anti Euro squad over the ocean, which is pretty good for her carreer (and her message).

 

 

 

 


Jazz Theme

 
7. Monday, May 15, 2006 8:28 PM
nuart RE: Ayaan Hirsi Ali on CONFRONTING Islam


 Member Since
 12/18/2005
 Posts:7632

 View Profile
 Send PM

Jazz turning another corner? Do tell. That was slightly illuminating. Who knew she was being hounded out of Holland and that she could become an "ILLEGAL ALIEN?" But what is with the Jewish angle? Is it the Mossad again? Are they trying to get her out? And what about those overseas "anti-Europe squad???" It's all getting very complex. I feel like Cuba.

PS Okay, I found this. Am I the only one who thinks Holden Caulfield when I hear someone being labeled a "PHONY?"

Expatica
May 13

Ayaan Hirsi Ali: hero or phony?


Dutch Immigration Minister Rita Verdonk claims to be decisive and consistent; she "steers a straight course through the sea". She says her immigration and asylum policies are strict but fair.

Perhaps then the Liberal Party (VVD) minister could tell us the difference between Ayaan Hirsi Ali and Taida Pasic?

Somali-born Hirsi Ali lied when she was 22 in order to get asylum in the Netherlands and improve her life.

Kosovar Taida Pasic, 18, effectively lied to get a tourist visa to re-enter the Netherlands in 2005 to complete the Dutch education she was receiving before her family was refused asylum here.

Verdonk took a personal interest in ensuring Pasic, whom she publicly branded a liar, was deported from the country before she could take her final exams here. She has to do that in Sarajevo, Bosnia.

How decisive and consistent. Verdonk does not like liars, she says, and liars don't get past her immigration officials. Well not now, anyway. Hirsi Ali is a different story.

Verdonk says Hirsi Ali would not have got in to the Netherlands had she been minister at the time. However Hirsi Ali has nothing to fear now despite the porkies she told 14 years ago.

News programme Zembla reported on 11 May that Hirsi Ali hid her actual name, Hirsi Magan, and her age when she sought asylum here in 1992. Immigration officials might otherwise have established she was under the care of the UNHCR in Kenya.

She was granted asylum here in a record five weeks. How come?

She told a heart-rending story about having to flee Somalia to escape an arranged marriage, went to a refugee camp in Kenya, and from there got to the Netherlands. Once here, she faced the constant fear of retribution from her angry family.

The right story for an asylum seeker. And she has made good in the intervening years. A member of parliament for the VVD, she has not flinched from her criticism of aspects of Islam and Muslim immigration despite numerous death threats.

She is accompanied by bodyguards everywhere she goes because of the threats and the murder of director Theo van Gogh. They collaborated on the short film Submission.

She has impressed the world - and annoyed many people too - by her forthright support of freedom of speech during the Danish cartoon controversy. Her ability to draw on her own experiences of the ill treatment of women and female circumcision lend great weight to her campaigning for emancipation of Muslim women.

It is disconcerting therefore to hear how cavalier Hirsi Ali can be when faced with questions about contradictions in her past. She admitted them on Zembla. She doesn't think this is a big deal.

Hirsi Ali was living in Kenya for over 10 years before coming here and didn't experience five civil wars in Somalia as prominent VVD member and current EU commissioner Nelie Kroes claimed in 2002.

Hirsi Ali said, and the VVD confirms, she told them back then she had lied to the immigration service. Why then did the VVD present Hirsi Ali as a person who survived the turmoil in Somalia?

And if Hirsi Ali was so afraid of retribution from her family why did she contact a Dutch-based family member on arrival. Why did she appear in a documentary made by the Dutch Muslim broadcaster within a year? Why did she maintain contact with her father? And why did members of her family tell Zembla that Hirsi Ali was present and happy at her wedding when she maintained she was neither.

Liberals don't care Hirsi Ali lied to get asylum in 1992

There are some anomalies here but it is important to keep this in perspective. As she said herself: asylum seekers tend to gild the lily to ensure they get residence permits. Who among us would not have told a few white lies to ensure a better life?

Hirsi Ali has bettered her life, and has championed causes that need determined champions. But one nagging question remains. Why is this former asylum seeker a member of the same party as Verdonk? This is the minister who wants to deport gays and Christian converts back to Iran. This is the minister who has vowed to keep economic migrants masquerading as refugees from getting into the country.

Why is it OK for Hirsi Ali to lie to make a better life for herself in the Netherlands, but Pasic can't even be allowed to stay a few weeks extra to finish her exams?


     
“Half a truth is often a great lie.”

 

Ben Franklin

 
8. Saturday, May 13, 2006 10:34 AM
Jazz RE: Ayaan Hirsi Ali on CONFRONTING Islam


 Member Since
 12/19/2005
 Posts:2214

 View Profile
 Send PM

"Jazz turning another corner? Do tell. That was slightly illuminating. Who knew she was being hounded out of Holland and that she could become an "ILLEGAL ALIEN?" But what is with the Jewish angle? Is it the Mossad again? Are they trying to get her out? And what about those overseas "anti-Europe squad???" It's all getting very complex. I feel like Cuba."

I feel for Ayaan' message, but she personally lost a lot of credibility with her very weak (terrible!) debates this last year.
I personally attended a couple of debates (as part of the audience) and it was a sad performance at least.
She clearly can't handle young intelligent and outspoken Muslim girls, but can't handle debate in general.
I think she is the laughing stock of most intelligent/educated outspoken Muslims, while she needs these boys and girls in the fight to liberate imo.

Most - if not all- of her fans are white/western people who already agreed with her before they heard of her.
That's cool, but she is in no way reaching those who need to be reached, which makes the whole thing pretty useless imo.

The Jewish angle; every conspiracy ends up being a 'Jewish thing', so you know .. just to make things faster and easier .. cut to the chase and stuff.

The overseas anti-Europe squad (sounds like a very bad German b movie to me);
I mean the particular groups who are walking away with Ayaan, people like Robert Spencer for instance (who's general message about Islam I feel for as well), but loads of blogs and such.
The constant anti-Europe nonsense and Ayaan are two pillars for so many right wing blogs today.
Most of the anti-Europe stuff is silly and without thought, and Ayaan brings nothing new and doesn’t know how to reach the people she is talking about.

ps: Rita Verdonk ("Iron Rita") has taken back her words, and Ayaan' case is being reopened.
Ayaan already confessed being a liar, so I don't think she makes a very good chance .. but everything can happen right.
The end result might be that she will be put on a plane to Africa without a passport.
That would be a sad thing (and I already know who will be celebrating) but no one is above justice or above the law in this case, so that might be a good sign as well.


Jazz Theme

 
9. Monday, May 15, 2006 8:28 PM
nuart RE: Ayaan Hirsi Ali on CONFRONTING Islam


 Member Since
 12/18/2005
 Posts:7632

 View Profile
 Send PM
QUOTE:

The overseas anti-Europe squad (sounds like a very bad German b movie to me);

I mean the particular groups who are walking away with Ayaan, people like Robert Spencer for instance (who's general message about Islam I feel for as well), but loads of blogs and such.The constant anti-Europe nonsense and Ayaan are two pillars for so many right wing blogs today.Most of the anti-Europe stuff is silly and without thought, and Ayaan brings nothing new and doesn’t know how to reach the people she is talking about.

ps: Rita Verdonk ("Iron Rita") has taken back her words, and Ayaan' case is being reopened.

Ayaan already confessed being a liar, so I don't think she makes a very good chance .. but everything can happen right.The end result might be that she will be put on a plane to Africa without a passport.That would be a sad thing (and I already know who will be celebrating) but no one is above justice or above the law in this case, so that might be a good sign as well.

Welly-well-well, too much anti-Europeanism for you, huh Jazz? Tee hee. Welcome to the world of silly thoughtless attacks.

Over here we've been living that life for a loooooooong time with much of the silly thoughtlessness coming from within. It is possible to look at the attacks as a badge of honor in many ways. Kind of shows your relevance, don't you think? At the same time, it' largely white noise. A constant drone like a toilet that won't stop running. You finally acclimate yourself to it and it is just another sound like the birds and the bees.

I would be willing to bet on a stack of Nietzsche tomes that she will NEVER be deported to Africa though. I am as certain of that as I am that Hillary Rodham Clinton will not be the 2008 Democratic Presidential candidate in the US. I will bet you any amount of Dutch chocolate shoes you like!

Robert Spencer is no genius but I like his Politically Incorrect Book on Islam though.

But that is an interesting bit of news on AHA (good initials) and the Muslim Youf debates. Since she is an apostate I doubt her line of reasoning is going to make many inroads toward moderating extreme Islam. Oh, well, keep checking MEMRI because there are scores and scores of Muslims from all parts of the Ummah who have a chance to make a great impact.


     
“Half a truth is often a great lie.”

 

Ben Franklin

 
10. Saturday, May 13, 2006 3:56 PM
Jazz RE: Ayaan Hirsi Ali on CONFRONTING Islam


 Member Since
 12/19/2005
 Posts:2214

 View Profile
 Send PM

That would be AHM, Ayaan Hirshi Magan .. she lied about her name.

Spencer' PIG is a good read, I agree.

I think there is a real possibility that Ayaan has got to leave the country, but I'm sure the US will welcome her with open arms (America is a better stage for her anyway).

The problem is more national I think, and mainly a problem for the VVD.
Rita verdonk and Ayaan are from the same political party, and there is a very big chance that Rita will lead that party coming year.

 

 


Jazz Theme

 
11. Monday, May 15, 2006 5:40 AM
Jazz RE: Ayaan Hirsi Ali on CONFRONTING Islam


 Member Since
 12/19/2005
 Posts:2214

 View Profile
 Send PM

Today the Volkskrant (yes another written medium, yuk) writes that Ayaan is indeed leaving Holland to go to the US.
They mention an official thingie this week.

 

 


Jazz Theme

 
12. Monday, May 15, 2006 7:42 AM
Jazz RE: Ayaan Hirsi Ali on CONFRONTING Islam


 Member Since
 12/19/2005
 Posts:2214

 View Profile
 Send PM

Geert zuigt, but not as hard as Wiegel zuigt for instance .. bunch of Vara rats .. or something in that line of not so zuigende thoughts.

This is where Ayaan is going to work:
http://www.pfaw.org/pfaw/general/default.aspx?oid=4456


Jazz Theme

 
13. Monday, May 15, 2006 9:14 AM
Jazz RE: Ayaan Hirsi Ali on CONFRONTING Islam


 Member Since
 12/19/2005
 Posts:2214

 View Profile
 Send PM
There's a thought indeed ..


Jazz Theme

 
14. Monday, May 15, 2006 10:17 AM
nuart RE: Ayaan Hirsi Ali on CONFRONTING Islam


 Member Since
 12/18/2005
 Posts:7632

 View Profile
 Send PM
QUOTE:

Today the Volkskrant (yes another written medium, yuk) writes that Ayaan is indeed leaving Holland to go to the US.
They mention an official thingie this week.

 

 

Not like the brazen giant of Greek fame,
with conquering limbs astride from land to land;
Here at our sea-washed, sunset gates shall stand
a mighty woman with a torch, whose flame
is the imprisoned lightning, and her name
Mother of Exiles. From her beacon-hand
Glows world-wide welcome; her mild eyes command
The air-bridged harbor that twin cities frame,
"Keep, ancient lands, your storied pomp!" cries she
with silent lips. "Give me your tired, your poor,
Your huddled masses yearning to breathe free,
The wretched refuse of your teeming shore,
Send these, the homeless, tempest-tost to me,
I lift my lamp beside the golden door!"


     
“Half a truth is often a great lie.”

 

Ben Franklin

 
15. Monday, May 15, 2006 8:29 PM
nuart RE: Ayaan Hirsi Ali on CONFRONTING Islam


 Member Since
 12/18/2005
 Posts:7632

 View Profile
 Send PM
QUOTE:

This is where Ayaan is going to work:
http://www.pfaw.org/pfaw/general/default.aspx?oid=4456

That was a pretty funny link, Jazz, with a selective view of the American Enterprise Institute.

People For the American Way might be described as left wing propagandists, but so it goes. Here are some of the People for the American Way (as opposed to those of us who Against the American Way). Deep thinkers all.

People For the American Way Foundation
Board of Directors
Norman Lear – Co-Chair
Alec Baldwin
Blair Brown
Bianca Jagger
Kathleen Turner

When you said she was embraced by the right wing, I thought she might be heading off to some Idaho Militiaman organization!

I love the AEI which is a brilliant group of Think Thankers including my fave -- the brilliant ex-CIA op, Reuel Marc Gerecht. Their seminars are often broadcast on CSPAN. Here's their website where you can compare and contrast to the Left Wing Extremist PFAW descriptions. Anyone who wants to get a true sense of what they're about -- and the group is varied -- should download some CSPAN video. Well informed, thoughtful, invigorating discussions! If she can't hold her own, it will quickly be evident at AEI.

http://www.aei.org/



     
“Half a truth is often a great lie.”

 

Ben Franklin

 
16. Monday, May 15, 2006 11:21 AM
Jazz RE: Ayaan Hirsi Ali on CONFRONTING Islam


 Member Since
 12/19/2005
 Posts:2214

 View Profile
 Send PM

It was just the name of the think tank I read on the website,  I don't read what I copy and paste  (it's the last rebellious nerve twist, whoohaa!)

 

 

 


Jazz Theme

 
17. Monday, May 15, 2006 2:18 PM
Jazz RE: Ayaan Hirsi Ali on CONFRONTING Islam


 Member Since
 12/19/2005
 Posts:2214

 View Profile
 Send PM

it's all happening very fast, so another update;

Because Ayaan lied about her name and age, the 'greencard' she revieved is not hers but for someone who doesnt exists.
Verdonk doesn't even have to take it away from her.

Ayaan is leaving Dutch politics tomorrow .. probably.

 

 


Jazz Theme

 
18. Monday, May 15, 2006 8:29 PM
nuart RE: Ayaan Hirsi Ali on CONFRONTING Islam


 Member Since
 12/18/2005
 Posts:7632

 View Profile
 Send PM

Wowee, zowee! I thought she was currently in the US. I remember reading she was at Harvard last week. Would they do this backstabbing while she's not even in Holland to defend herself? Names shmames. Do you think when she was a young woman she had the intention of plotting her rise to political fame on a phony name or was it simply done for the assurance that she would receive protection from the state?

Boy oh boy, I didn't know she was persona non grata with the people of Holland. I thought it was just with the few. Here in the US it's almost impossible to be deported. My my, this went quickly. I wonder how long she knew this was in the works.

This from a lecture at the American Jewish Committee last week in Washington:

She was taught that the Jews were to blame for the war in Somalia, for driving the Palestinians out of their homes, for the fact that no water came out of Somalian taps. ‘If my mother was unkind to me, I knew the Jews were definitely behind it’, she said. The Jews, she was taught, were evil, had evil powers and used these to evil ends.

Below the full store from Expatica. Note the nonsensical final note re/AEI. If Jazz is correct and she's not the sharpest tool in the shed, that is what will make her uncomfortable not the so called "religiously tinted world view."

Hirsi Ali - reactions

She's no loss to Netherlands - Wiegel


The coming departure of Ayaan Hirsi Ali from the Dutch parliament is "no loss for the Liberal Party (VVD)" or for the Lower House of Parliament, former VVD leader Hans Wiegel said on Monday. He was commenting on the news, Hirsi Ali is moving to the US to work for a political think tank American Enterprise Institute (AEI). Wiegel, who is known for speaking his mind, told a radio programme Hirsi Ali is a "brave woman" but her standpoints are polarising. He cited her views on the freedom of education and minority groups as examples. "I did not agree with this line," he said. Wiegel said he did not think much will be heard of Hirsi Ali again once she takes up her job in the US. "That I don't find so bad," he said.

Departure is painful - Van Aartsen


Former VVD political leader Jozias van Aartsen expressed regret at Ayaan Hirsi Ali's decision to go to America. "It is painful for Dutch society and politics that she is leaving parliament," Van Aartsen said in a statement. "The Netherlands complains all the time about grey politicians who don't dare speak their minds. Here we had someone who does and did that, and we were very negative about that."

Muslim group not mourning

The Contact Organisation for Muslims and Government (CMO) indicated on Monday it was not sorry that Ayaan Hirsi Ali is going to American to work. Her strong attacks on Islam have caused "a lot of damage", CMO secretary Nasr Joemman said. "I celebrate that she is leaving the Netherlands," Joemman said. "I hope that by her departure we can move forward with building a harmonious society."

European minister wishes MP well

European minister Atzo Nicolaï wished his party colleague Ayaan Hirsi Ali every success on hearing she is moving to America. "It is nice if a MP does not resign directly after elections, but can move on to other things at the end of a period," Nicolaï said after a meeting of European ministers in Brussels on Monday. He said he did not have the impression the move was something that came up in the last few weeks. "I think this has been thought about for longer."

Hirsi Ali 'out of place at AEI'

Researcher Peter van Ham of the Clingendael Institute said Ayaan Hirsi Ali will be out of place at the American Enterprise Institute (AEI). "You would sooner expect Geert Wilders to be there than Hirsi Ali," he said in reaction to the news she is leaving the Netherlands to work for the AEI. According to Van Ham the AEI is a very conservative institute that has flourished since President George W. Bush came to power. "It is definitely not a liberal bastion," he said. Hirsi Ali, he predicted, will not be encouraged to express liberal views about euthanasia, homosexuality and abortion. "The people who work there have a very religiously-tinted worldview. I think Hirsi Ali will feel totally claustrophobic there."

And this from Peak Talk:

Monday, May 15, 2006
HIRSI ALI'S FALL

Judging form the many e-mails over the past weekend it is clear that the latest installment in the Ayaan Hirsi Ali saga is probably one of the more spectacular and at the same time more controversial ones. In short, last Thursday a television documentary tried to verify the various claims Hirsi Ali has made about her past and the way in which she became a refugee seeking political asylum in The Netherlands in the early 90s. What is clear is that she did indeed lie in order to obtain refugee status, a fact she wholeheartedly admits. Murkier are the details surrounding her arranged marriage and the way in which she tried to extract herself from it.

The tone of the documentary called "Saint Ayaan" made by the VARA – which is a left-of-center public broadcaster affiliated with both the Labour Party and organized labour – clearly underlines its intent: to take down Hirsi Ali. Leon de Winter points out in his blog that the left may have been down but hardly out, and is now in full swing to restore the Dutch age of politically correct consensus by publicly executing Hirsi Ali.

That is a correct assumption. But what has not been discussed in detail is that the Dutch right, and notably Hirsi Ali’s own liberal party (VVD) may have decided that it is time to get shot of her. Ayaan’s lies will now be the subject of a formal investigation by Immigration Minister Rita Verdonk, who as it happens is also part of the VVD and is in the middle of hotly contested leadership struggle (to be concluded later this month) in which she faces a more moderate and centrist candidate. So, if Verdonk’s aim is to gain control over the VVD she will have to not only make sure that by investigating Hirsi Ali she is living up to her ‘going by the book’ reputation, but she will have to placate her party’s more centrist members. As such, Hirsi Ali is of no real use to her, and it is Verdonk herself who has grabbed the "less-government, tough on immigration" mantle that has been vacant following Fortuyn’s and Van Gogh’s respective murders. Hirsi Ali has served her purpose by formulating a number of highly controversial positions, something that no one previously dared saying, and now that the word is out it is up to others to take the message forward.

The other aspect that should be underlined here is the deep resentment that success and ambition usually generate in The Netherlands. Dynamic careers, success, outspokenness, standing out in the crowd are things that have always been frowned upon, although that has changed a bit in recent years I guess. Still, the Dutch coined the phrase “act normal, that is strange enough” and a very ambitious black Muslim woman who built up a spectacular political career with international allure by holding a mirror in front of the complacent and politically lethargic Dutch was of course not something that would be rewarded with eternal gratitude. Intelligent as she is, Hirsi Ali must have been keenly aware that she was bound to get into real trouble and by that I do not mean a jihadist ready to kill her. No, her once receptive hosts and former friends will now have the honor of wielding the knife.

Coming so quickly after the court ruling in the case that seeks to evict her from her house it is hard not to escape the conclusion that some sort of concerted effort is under way to get rid of her. As it stands, I believe that both the left and the right have a vested interest in bringing this about and without the support of her own party Hirsi Ali’s chances to hang on and run on the VVD ticket in the general election next year are remote.

Question is, should Hirsi Ali resign or otherwise be demoted from her present prominent role in the party on the basis of her past lies? The answer to that has to be affirmative. No one holding elected office should be exempt from the most simple ethical and moral test and the same goes for Hirsi Ali. What should not happen, but what I am afraid is will happen, is a very public humiliation of Hirsi Ali and with that of a lot of the ideas she stands for. In the past I have argued that she eventually would make her way across the Atlantic to find employ at a major think tank, a notion she herself always dismissed. But the latest turn of events will probably force her to once more make a dramatic move, although this time she will not have to lie about it.

Reading all this stuff over, yes, I agree. She'll be more at home in the US and A.


     
“Half a truth is often a great lie.”

 

Ben Franklin

 
19. Monday, May 15, 2006 3:27 PM
Jazz RE: Ayaan Hirsi Ali on CONFRONTING Islam


 Member Since
 12/19/2005
 Posts:2214

 View Profile
 Send PM

It's odd (at least!) how so many of the people around her join the backstabbing of her.

The negative/weak elements of her public performance I wrote about, are not my only thoughts about her.
I stand by what I wrote about her before (also in PM's and such).
She is a balsy intelligent and powerful woman, and I know for sure she's going to become even bigger in the US and A.

It's not that most of the Dutch want her deported.
There is a big political powerplay going and a bunch of other (outside of the political arena) take the oppertunity to dance on her 'grave'.

The Dutch do want her out of parliament though (according to polls).
I think that is not particular weird in a functioning democracy, after so many lies of her.
The people of Holland voted for a government who would act firm and according to stricked laws.
Now, I don't know if that is a smart move (different discussion), but people did.
The VVD party is the main sybol of that toughness.
Both Rita Verdonk and Ayaan Hirshi Magan are from that same party .. the irony! 

With respect to my grandparents;
Holland has a tradition of holding laws more dear than anything else.
Most Jews (%) were deported from this little country, after Hitler made little rules for that.
oops, a Hitler comparison. 

 

 


Jazz Theme

 
20. Tuesday, May 16, 2006 9:40 AM
nuart RE: Ayaan Hirsi Ali on CONFRONTING Islam


 Member Since
 12/18/2005
 Posts:7632

 View Profile
 Send PM

Her statement is in.  It is still rather shocking to me that she is, in effect, being tossed out of a free country.

 
Tweede-Kamerfractie / Persverklaring Ayaan Hirsi Ali (Engels)
door Ayaan Hirsi Ali

I came to Holland in the summer of 1992 because I wanted to be able to determine my own future. I didn’t want to be forced into a destiny that other people had chosen for me, so I opted for the protection of the rule of law. Here in Holland, I found freedom and opportunities, and I took those opportunities to speak out against religious terror.

In January 2003, at the invitation of the VVD party, I became a member of parliament. I accepted the VVD’s invitation on the condition that I would be the party’s spokesman for the emancipation of women and the integration of immigrants.

What exactly did I want to achieve?

First of all I wanted to put the oppression of immigrant women -- especially Muslim women – squarely on the Dutch political agenda. Second, I wanted Holland to pay attention to the specific cultural and religious issues that were holding back many ethnic minorities, instead of always taking a one-sided approach that focused only on their socio-economic circumstances. Lastly, I wanted politicians to grasp the fact that major aspects of Islamic doctrine and tradition, as practiced today, are incompatible with the open society.

Now I have to ask myself, have I accomplished that task?

I have stumbled often in my political career. It has sometimes been frustrating and slow. However, I am completely certain that I have, in my own way, succeeded in contributing to the debate. Issues related to Islam – such as impediments to free speech; refusal of the separation of Church and State; widespread domestic violence; honor killings; the repudiation of wives; and Islam’s failure to condemn genital mutilation -- these subjects can no longer be swept under the carpet in our country’s capital. Some of the measures that this government has begun taking give me satisfaction. Many illusions of how easy it will be to establish a multicultural society have disappeared forever. We are now more realistic and more open in this debate, and I am proud to have contributed to that process.

Meanwhile, the ideas which I espouse have begun spreading to other countries. In recent years I have given speeches and attended debates in many European countries and in the United States. For months now, I have felt that I needed to make a decision: should I go on in Dutch politics, or should I now transfer my ideas to an international forum?

In the fall of 2005 I told Gerrit Zalm and Jozias van Aartsen, the leaders of the VVD, that I would not be a candidate for the parliamentary elections in 2007. I had decided to opt for a more international platform, because I wanted to contribute to the international debate on the emancipation of Muslim women and the complex relationship between Islam and the West.

Now that I am announcing that I will resign from Dutch politics, I would like to thank the members of the VVD for my years in parliament – to thank them for inviting me to stand for parliament, and -- perhaps more importantly -- for putting up with me while I was there, for this has been in many ways a rough ride for us all. I want to thank my other colleagues here in parliament for their help, although some of our debates have been sharp. (Femke Halsema, thank you especially for that!). I would also like to thank the 30,758 people who in January 2003 trusted their preference vote to a newcomer.

But why am I not remaining in parliament for my full term, until next year’s election? Why, after only three and a half years, have I decided to resign from the Lower Chamber?

It is common knowledge that threats against my life began building up ever since I first talked about Islam publicly, in the spring of 2002. Months before I even entered politics, my freedom of movement was greatly curtailed, and that became worse after Theo van Gogh was murdered in 2004. I have been obliged to move house so many times I have lost count. The direct cause for the ending of my membership in parliament is that on April 27 of this year, a Dutch court ruled that I must once again leave my home, because my neighbors filed a complaint that they could not feel safe living next to me. The Dutch government will appeal this verdict and I grateful for that, because how on earth will other people whose lives are threatened manage to find a place to stay if this verdict is allowed to rest? However, this appeal does not alter my situation: I have to leave my apartment by the end of August.

Another reason for my departure is the discussion that has arisen from a TV program, The Holy Ayaan, which was aired on May 11. This program centered on two issues: the story that I told when I was applying for asylum here in Holland, and questions about my forced marriage.

I have been very open about the fact that when I applied for asylum in the Netherlands in 1992, I did so under a false name and with a fabricated story. In 2002, I spoke on national television about the conditions of my arrival, and I said then that I fabricated a story in order to be able to receive asylum here. Since that TV program I have repeated this dozens of times, in Dutch and international media. Many times I have truthfully named my father and given my correct date of birth. (You will find a selection of these articles in the press folder). I also informed the VVD leadership and members of this fact when I was invited to stand for parliament.

I have said many times that I am not proud that I lied when I sought asylum in the Netherlands. It was wrong to do so. I did it because I felt I had no choice. I was frightened that if I simply said I was fleeing a forced marriage, I would be sent back to my family. And I was frightened that if I gave my real name, my clan would hunt me down and find me. So I chose a name that I thought I could disappear with – the real name of my grandfather, who was given the birth-name Ali. I claimed that my name was Ayaan Hirsi Ali, although I should have said it was Ayaan Hirsi Magan.


You probably are wondering, what is my real name?

I am Ayaan, the daughter of Hirsi, who is the son of a man who took the name of Magan. Magan was the son of Isse, who was the son of Guleid, who was the son of Ali. He was the son of Wai’ays, who was the son of Muhammad. He was the son of Ali, who was the son of Umar. Umar was the son of Osman, who was the son of Mahamud. This is my clan, and therefore, in Somalia, this is my name: Ayaan Hirsi Magan Isse Guleid Ali Wai’ays Muhammad Ali Umar Osman Mahamud.

Following the May 11 television broadcast, legal questions have been raised about my naturalization as a Dutch citizen. Minister Verdonk has written to me saying that my passport will be annulled, because it was issued to a person who does not hold my real name. I am not at liberty to discuss the legal issues in this case.

Now for the questions about my forced marriage. Last week’s TV program cast doubt on my credibility in that respect, and the final conclusion of the documentary is that all this is terribly complicated. Let me tell you, it’s not so complex. The allegations that I willingly married my distant cousin, and was present at the wedding ceremony, are simply untrue. This man arrived in Nairobi from Canada, asked my father for one of his five daughters, and my father gave him me. I can assure you my father is not a man who takes no for an answer. Still, I refused to attend the formal ceremony, and I was married regardless. Then, on my way to Canada -- during a stopover in Germany -- I traveled to the Netherlands and asked for asylum here. In all simplicity this is what happened, nothing more and nothing less. For those who are interested in the intimate details of my transition from a pre-modern society to a modern one, and how I came to love what the West stands for, please read my memoir, which is due to be published this fall.

To return to the present day, may I say that it is difficult to live with so many threats on your life and such a level of police protection. It is difficult to work as a parliamentarian if you have nowhere to live. All that is difficult, but not impossible. It has become impossible since last night, when Minister Verdonk informed me that she would strip me of my Dutch citizenship.

I am therefore preparing to leave Holland. But the questions for our society remain. The future of Islam in our country; the subjugation of women in Islamic culture; the integration of the many Muslims in the West: it is self-deceit to imagine that these issues will disappear.

I will continue to ask uncomfortable questions, despite the obvious resistance that they elicit. I feel that I should help other people to live in freedom, as many people have helped me. I personally have gone through a long and sometimes painful process of personal growth in this country. It began with learning to tell the truth to myself, and then the truth about myself: I strive now to also tell the truth about society as I see it.

That transition from becoming a member of a clan to becoming a citizen in an open society is what public service has come to mean for me. Only clear thinking and strong action can lead to real change, and free many people within our society from the mental cage of submission. The idea that I can contribute to their freedom, whether in the Netherlands or in another country, gives me deep satisfaction.

Ladies and Gentlemen, as of today, I resign from Parliament. I regret that I will be leaving the Netherlands, the country which has given me so many opportunities and enriched my life, but I am glad that I will be able to continue my work. I will go on.

Susan 


     
“Half a truth is often a great lie.”

 

Ben Franklin

 
21. Tuesday, May 16, 2006 11:31 AM
Jazz RE: Ayaan Hirsi Ali on CONFRONTING Islam


 Member Since
 12/19/2005
 Posts:2214

 View Profile
 Send PM

It's not such a happy day.

With a little luck Rita Verdonk will have to leave parliament as well pretty soon .. just a little luck ..

 

 


Jazz Theme

 
22. Friday, June 2, 2006 1:44 PM
nuart RE: Ayaan Hirsi Ali on CONFRONTING Islam


 Member Since
 12/18/2005
 Posts:7632

 View Profile
 Send PM

So now she's in Philadelphia where she is being mistaken for Iman or Naomi Campbell. Nice long article rom the Philadelphia Inquirer.

"Freedom Fighter."

http://www.philly.com/mld/inquirer/news/special_packages/sunday_review/14710997.htm

Susan

 


     
“Half a truth is often a great lie.”

 

Ben Franklin

 
23. Monday, June 12, 2006 5:41 PM
nuart RE: Ayaan Hirsi Ali on CONFRONTING Islam


 Member Since
 12/18/2005
 Posts:7632

 View Profile
 Send PM

Another lady confronting Islam, Oriana Fallaci in the New Yorker Magazine. She's a pistol! A long information-packed piece.

http://www.newyorker.com/fact/content/articles/060605fa_fact

Susan

 

PS  Oriana Fallaci's trial began today in Italy.  Charges:  Defaming Islam!  Who knew that was against in Italy?  And there are more than a handful in Europe who decry the US infringement on civil liberties. 

Italian author to be tried for defaming Islam
Associated Press, THE JERUSALEM POST     Jun. 12, 2006

Italian author and veteran journalist Oriana Fallaci goes on trial Monday, charged with defaming Islam in a 2004 book. Fallaci, who lives in New York, was not expected to attend the hearing in Bergamo, northern Italy.

Muslim activist Adel Smith filed a lawsuit against Fallaci, charging that some passages in her book, "The Strength of Reason," were offensive to Islam. Smith's lawyer cited a phrase from the book that refers to Islam as "a pool ... that never purifies."

Fallaci told The Associated Press last year that "I have expressed my opinion through the written word through my books, that is all."
 


     
“Half a truth is often a great lie.”

 

Ben Franklin

 
24. Monday, June 12, 2006 5:47 PM
nuart RE: Ayaan Hirsi Ali on CONFRONTING Islam


 Member Since
 12/18/2005
 Posts:7632

 View Profile
 Send PM

Now here's the Alarab.com version of the Oriana Fallaci trial:

Trial of Fallaci starts

The trial of Italian author Oriana Fallaci accused of defaming Islam in a book published in 2004 started on Monday in the northern city of Bergamo and was immediately adjourned to 26 June.

 Fallaci, 76, did not attend the hearing to protest against a case she has described as "unforgivable." Adel Smith, the head of the small Muslim Union of Italy, brought the veteran reporter to court for offending Islam in the book "The Strength of Reason."

 A group in France unsuccessfully sought to stop distribution of another best-selling essay of the author, "The Rage and the Pride," written in the aftermath of the September 11 “terror” attacks on the US.

 In "The Strength of Reason" Fallaci accuses Europe of having sold out to what she describes as an Islamic invasion.

 She is reportedly charged with insulting Islam in the book in more than 18 sentences.

 "Distoring the thought of a person, picking up a word here and another there ... is illegitimate, illegal, criminal," the author told conservative daily Il Foglio in an interview published over the weekend.

 Smith is known in Italy as a radical activist. He became a well known figure in 2003 when he unsuccessfully tried to have a crucifix removed from his son's elementary school classroom in central Italy.


     
“Half a truth is often a great lie.”

 

Ben Franklin

 

New Topic | Post Reply Page 1 of 1 :: << | 1 | >>
Politics > Ayaan Hirsi Ali on CONFRONTING Islam


Users viewing this Topic (1)
1 Guest


This page was generated in 218 ms.