 |
|
|
|
|
|
Politics
> From a Former Leftist
|
|
New Topic |
Post Reply
|
| 1. Wednesday, June 3, 2009 9:32 AM |
| nuart |
From a Former Leftist |
Member Since 12/18/2005 Posts:7632
View Profile Send PM
|
...this amoozing column from a fave website "American Thinker" gave me a chuckle of self-recognition. I remember that hilarious episode of Maude she cites. On the other hand, I was looking forward to The Goode Family but thought it was muy unfunny. And speaking of parking regulations, have you seen these special spaces allotted to Pregnant Women??? At a time when they SHOULD be walking! Unbelievable they get parking spaces in the same vicinity as the Handicapped Parking. Unconscionable. Susan

|
|
June 03, 2009Ask Robin: A Recovering Liberal Addresses Some of Your Burning QuestionsBy Robin of Berkeley
American Thinker's resident recovering liberal answers readers.
Dear Robin:
How can we trust that you are really who you say you are? How do we know you are not a liberal impersonating a conservative?
Marty
Hi Marty:
Busted! My articles are actually ghostwritten by Bill Ayers.
Don't sweat it, Mart-T, my conscientious editor at American Thinker, a Bay Area guy, has met and vetted me. So I'm for real. Anyway, dude, do you think I could make this stuff up?
* * Dear Robin:
What draws otherwise smart people to being a progressive liberal? How do they accept the generalized hate?
Julia
Hey Julia:
Let me speak for myself here.
My liberal turn on's: (This is like Match.com)
1. It was exciting: I was a bored, lost suburban kid growing up in a secular Jewish home with no direction to speak of. I spent too much time alone watching TV. My parents were heavy drinkers and partiers, and my brother hated me from the day I was born and made my life a living hell. So, it wasn't a blast, and when I got into my teens, I numbed it all out with drugs. Doing political work in young adulthood, I suddenly had a purpose, a reason to get up in the morning. Working with others in groups, marching with thousands of people, was not only an emotional high but a physical thrill, almost like an aphrodisiac. A legal high. And feeling like you're saving the world is positively orgasmic.
2. The Left is seen as cool. The Right is viewed as stodgy, dull, and selfish. Franken is cool. Newt is not. And many of us drawn to the Left were unpopular, lonely children. By being far left, a bunch of misfits can fit in.
3. It was all I knew. Info in Liberalville is censored and you believe what you hear. It becomes a form of brainwashing. And everyone around me was Left. We're pack animals and tend to follow the herd, for better or for worse.
4. Being progressive (what a high falootin' word) makes you feel good about yourself: generous, altruistic, ever loving and accepting (even though they wish terminal diseases on conservatives). "We can save the world, rearrange the world, it's dying to get better." (Crosby, Still, etc.) Who can argue with that ego trip:?
OK, now for turn off's:
1. Frankly, there have been a lot of things that have bugged the crap out of me for years (maybe this was why it was easier for me to wake up). The rampant street crime and aggressive panhandling are totally out of control. And liberals excusing antisocial behavior ("He didn't mean to beat the living daylights out of that little old lady, he is a victim of white privilege, blah blah blah,") makes me want to hurl. They need their own recovery program for mega codependency (LibCo?).
2. The Left portrays itself as mellow and chill, but bigger control freaks you have never seen in your life. The Berkeley laws are draconian. Try finding a parking lot since none are available; cars are the devil's handiwork. The city restricts business licenses (again, to keep out those bloody cars) so I had to open my office in a nearby town. And light up a cigarette and watch a menacing crowd encircle you; Berkeley has outlawed smoking in almost every outdoor locale.
I can go on and on. . . But you get the point. Big Brother is alive and well in Berkeley, though he's traveling high on the hog via Air Force One these days.
3. The mean stuff. I just don't do mean. Love Ellen, Detest Janeane. Even when I was a liberal, I was nice one (by Berkeley, though not Alabama, standards). And my spiritual faith compels me to treat others with respect. But even though I'm nice, I'm not sweet. I don't put up with crap. But I'm generally nice about it.
So, looking back, the seeds of conservatism were in me all along. And when I got older and wiser, the party got meaner and greener (don't get me started on the green fascism out here). I can't speak for every liberal but this is my tale. In the end, humans are rather simple creatures. We stay with the familiar until it becomes unbearable and we have another option. Liberalism didn't work for me anymore. Let's hope many others reach the same conclusion by 2010.
* *
Dear Robin:
I don't forgive you. You indoctrinated our young people.
Phil
Yo Phil:
No worries. I never worked at the university or any other schools. And, anyway, you don't have to indoctrinate people in Berkeley. Everyone drinks from the same Kool-Aid.
Dear Robin:
Ooh, get me a tissue box. You and your readers are weak.
Sam
Hey Sam:
I have three responses to your letter. One: it's offensive and unseemly to mock my readers and me.
Two: your being so hostile to strangers makes me sad. Clearly one or both of your parents disrespected you and trampled on your feelings.
My upbringing was like that so I can relate. But I responded by never wanting to inflict the same type of pain on others. Take my word for it, Sam. It's much cooler to be kind.
Third: Bro, it's my party and I'll cry if I want to.
* *
Dear Robin:
You couldn't have been a liberal because you have a sense of humor.
Liz
Hello, Lizzy:
Funny you should say this! My motto in life is an old Wavy Gravy quote (no I wasn't at Woodstock): If you don't have a sense of humor, it's not funny!
The Left has become way too serious and sanctimonious for my tastes. But it wasn't always that way. I recently rented the first season of Maude, a show I enjoyed in my youth. I was astonished at how Maude, the white liberal, is affectionately teased throughout for her preachy white guilt. When she goes shopping for a "maid" (that's what they called them then), she insists on hiring a black one to "help" some needy person. When the confident Florida shows up, Maude is so condescending that Florida quits. Florida explains, "I'd rather work for a racist than a white liberal because at least racists won't try to change me." They reconcile, of course, and Florida is a major player on the show, reflecting back to Maude her patronizing ways. The lesson back then to whites: lighten up and laugh at yourself. And be very careful that your crusade for social justice isn't just another form of white arrogance.
If this show ran today, it wouldn't have lasted one episode (the Left would have rioted). And yet it was a runaway hit in the 1970's. Watching it bummed me out. How far we've come, or we've sunk, courtesy of the Thought Police. And liberals say conservatives are uptight and boring!
(By the way, there's a new summer replacement comedy called The Goode Family on ABC on Wednesday at 9 pm which pokes fun at the liberal, PC Police. Irreverent and refreshing. I give it a month at best before the network pulls it in fear of the wrath of Big O.)
Later. . . Robin A frequent contributor to American Thinker, Robin is a recovering liberal marooned in Berkeley and a psychotherapist in private practice. . She'd like to thank American Thinker readers for their helpful, generous, and kind comments.
“Half a truth is often a great lie.” Ben Franklin
|
| 2. Wednesday, June 3, 2009 10:02 AM |
| Booth |
RE: From a Former Leftist |
Member Since 8/20/2006 Posts:4388
View Profile Send PM
|
I am white but feel no guilt for it, am I secretly conservative?
|
| 3. Wednesday, June 3, 2009 10:09 AM |
| coolspringsj |
RE: From a Former Leftist |
Member Since 8/8/2007 Posts:3412
View Profile Send PM
|
QUOTE:I am white but feel no guilt for it, am I secretly conservative?
|
Yes.
"Harry, I'm going to let you in on a little secret. Every day, once a day, give yourself a present. Don't plan it, don't wait for it, just let it happen. Could be a new shirt at the men's store, a catnap in your office chair, or two cups of good, hot, black coffee. Like this." -Dale Cooper
|
| 4. Wednesday, June 3, 2009 10:51 AM |
| nuart |
RE: From a Former Leftist |
Member Since 12/18/2005 Posts:7632
View Profile Send PM
|
QUOTE:QUOTE:I am white but feel no guilt for it, am I secretly conservative?
|
Yes. |
Top secret.
“Half a truth is often a great lie.” Ben Franklin
|
| 5. Wednesday, June 3, 2009 10:55 AM |
| bio_hazard |
RE: From a Former Leftist |
Member Since 7/7/2008 Posts:385
View Profile Send PM
|
I'm so glad we have this guy to sum up the liberal experience! :) Anxiously awaiting his next columns "Berkeley car art not gas efficient" and "I don't like girls who don't shave their legs"
If you like strip malls and acres of parking around your Wallmart you probably wouldn't like Berkeley. I bet less liberal cities would have similar parking problems though: people who can't afford SF live there, plus it has one of the best universities in the world which brings people into the city every day.
Panhandling is really common, and I think businesses have a legitimate complaint that the city could do more to spruce up Telegraph ave. Crime is much more of a bummer, but tends to be spill-over from Oakland or hitting soft-targets at the university.
|
| 6. Wednesday, June 3, 2009 11:04 AM |
| Booth |
RE: From a Former Leftist |
Member Since 8/20/2006 Posts:4388
View Profile Send PM
|
| QUOTE: I'm so glad we have this guy to sum up the liberal experience! :) Anxiously awaiting his next columns "Berkeley car art not gas efficient" and "I don't like girls who don't shave their legs" | He is a she.
|
| 7. Wednesday, June 3, 2009 11:55 AM |
| nuart |
RE: From a Former Leftist |
Member Since 12/18/2005 Posts:7632
View Profile Send PM
|
Yes, she is a she. Here's what she wrote about her conversion. Tell me, any liberal or leftist or socialists who are reading this if there's anything familiar in her sensibilities.
May 21, 2009
How to Deprogram a Liberal in One Year Or Less By Robin of Berkeley So what do you do when you realize that everything you've ever thought and believed no longer worked for you? Where do you go when the bubble of progressive politics bursts in your face and you're left in the leftist place on earth? It seems that the choices are as follows: either you cling to your beliefs even more zealously and attack anyone who dares to disagree. Or, if you're like me, you embark on a journey of discovery and recovery.
I wrote another piece recently for American Thinker, a letter of amends to conservatives. In it I described why I transformed from a Berkeley leftist to a talk radio loving conservative the last 1 1/2 years. I realized the Democratic Party wasn't what I thought, that it had mutated into something mean and rough, and that I had probably been living in a fantasy world all along. I very much appreciated the outpouring of support, wisdom, and forgiveness from American Thinker readers.
Many said something to the effect of: Robin, congrats, but what in the world took you so long? So let me explain. I wasn't just your garden variety liberal who voted Democrat and that was about it. I was a true believer. A zealot. Like many leftists who had abandoned Judeo-Christian religion, I worshipped at the altar of liberalism. For instance, I never missed watching the Democratic National Convention. I watched every speech, with tissue box handy. (What kind of a freak was I anyway?) The Democratic Party symbolized hope, love, compassion, promise, everything that was good and holy in the world. I gave money, my time, my heart, my soul. I cried with joy when Democrats won; I was distraught when they lost.
I was programmed from birth to be a devout liberal. My dad, a hard working first generation Russian Jew, would lecture me on a regular basis, "The Democrats are the party of the little people. The Republicans are the party of the rich guy." He would also get a little weepy when he watched the DNC (so that must be where I got it from). One of our rare moments of bonding was reading the newspapers together on opposite ends of the couch, interrupting each other with stories about the bad Republicans and the heroic Democrats.
When I was in high school in the early 70's in New York, I wrote impassioned essays on civil rights and on feminism. In college, in the days before universities became indoctrination factories, I searched for politically left classes, and took every one I could find. I spent years in consciousness raising groups lambasting male oppression with other angry feminists, and yelled "Two Four Six Eight, Pornography is Woman Hate," at numerous marches.
When I was 26, I parked myself in the People's Republic of Berkeley, CA, the epicenter of the far left. I came as a liberal but soon morphed into a leftist as most people here do. In Berkeley, San Francisco, Oakland, and the outlying towns, there is no Republican Party. Literally. There are only Democrats running against other Democrats. I recall years ago going to vote at a time when there were separate lines for Democrats and Republicans. The Democrats' line was a mile long. The Republican's was free and clear. After we all stood there waiting for 45 minutes, a brave young man walked up to the Republican booth and quickly voted. I still recall the cackles and giggles as we pointed and stared at this odd, exotic bird that had come to perch for a brief while.
So maybe you get now how hard it was, how disorienting and destabilizing and crazy making it was, when I realized about 1 1/2 years ago that I no longer believed in liberalism. I walked around in a confused state for weeks. Being a Democrat, a liberal, a far left radical from Berkeley was a big part of my identity. So who the heck was I if I weren't a leftist? And what in the world would I do, given that my husband, all my friends, and all my psychotherapist clients were liberal and I would be public enemy #1 if I told anyone? Converting from Islam to Judaism, yet still hanging out in front of the old mosque in Kabul, probably would have been easier.
After weeks of shuffling around like a zombie, it was time to do something about it. The first step, I decided, was deprogramming myself from decades of liberal propaganda. Out went books by Howard Zinn, Noam Chomsky, Michael Parenti, and various 9/11 conspiracy books. In came Mark Levin, Ben Stein, Ron Paul, and Ayn Rand. I heard something vaguely about Talk Radio, so I scanned my AM dial, and found Michael Savage. I was shocked and offended by his diatribes -- but also oddly intrigued. I found many others: Limbaugh, Hannity, Levin, Boortz, Medved, all of whom became my "sponsors" in recovery this last year. I found wonderfully insightful websites like American Thinker.
To my disbelief, the more I listened and read, the more these folks made sense. For instance, at first I couldn't understand why so many conservatives expressed concern about morality issues, like gay marriage. Berkeley is Lesbian Central, and I know many good hearted gay people. But the more I learned, the more I started getting the larger picture; that conservatives were not necessarily impugning the character of gay people, but they were alarmed at the breakdown of traditional values. If the basic structure of society goes, e.g., traditional marriage, religion, patriotism, common language, what remains? If everything becomes fluid, what is there to hold onto? Without any moral structure and traditions, a society descends into anarchy and mob rule, as it is clearly doing today.
As I educated myself, I started thinking and rethinking. I'd wake up in the middle of the night with the sudden realization that deeply held beliefs made no sense. Take the anti war stance of the left. Noble and sanctimonious and all that. But how easy it is to sit back and preach peace when you have an army defending you; to rail against the U.S. when you are protected by free speech laws; to demonize Israel, when you've never lived through the murderous pogroms of Tsarist Russia or the Holocaust. How hypocritical to lambast Big Business while you are making money from their stocks in your mutual fund portfolio (that is, until Obama took over). And how ludicrous to admire Chavez, Castro and all things socialist, when the closest experience you've had to standing on a bread line is queuing up for goat cheese/arugula pizza at Whole Foods.
And this love affair with Radical Islam -- what's up with that? I had previously thought of Islam as a quaint, folksy religion. But when I started actually reading about it, especially Dr. Phyllis Chesler's illuminating books and web site, I realized extremist Muslims were advocating some seriously scary stuff, like destroying Israel and the West. I had been oblivious of the horrendous treatment of women: the honor killings, beheadings, genital mutilation. It now seemed like the height of naivety, if not masochism, to embrace with open arms people who want to kill you. While as a liberal I was socialized to believe everyone was good, all cultures were the same, and We Are The World, We Are The Children, I began to understand that evil exists. The emergence of evil always offers warnings signs, and we ignore them at our peril.
Though exhausted from lack of sleep, I also started waking up. I realized, to my utter incredulity, that conservatives made sense, and that I was one of them. I recalled Mark Twain's quip about his father: When Twain was a teenager, he thought his father was the stupidest man in the world; but when he became a young man in his 20's, his father had many intelligent things to say. Twain couldn't believe how much his father had learned in those years! Like Twain, I grew up and saw the world as it is. Yes it would be nice to save the planet, to eliminate hunger, and to make everyone good and righteous. But humans don't have the power to do that. To walk around, as I did, with utopian images that didn't match reality was to view life through the eyes of a child. An adult understands that civility matters, people need to be held accountable for their behavior, and protecting yourself and your country are moral imperatives.
So it took about a year, but my deprogramming has been successful. I'm comfortable in my own skin, feel more alive than I have in years, and am excited by all I'm learning and becoming. Now when I listen to Sean Hannity's theme song, "Let Freedom Ring," I get a little misty eyed (some things never change). I only hope and pray (yes I'm doing that more too) that the US survives when the Democrats are done "changing" it. But if this lifelong left winger from Berkeley can wake up, hopefully others will also do so before it's too late.
“Half a truth is often a great lie.” Ben Franklin
|
| 8. Wednesday, June 3, 2009 12:03 PM |
| coolspringsj |
RE: From a Former Leftist |
Member Since 8/8/2007 Posts:3412
View Profile Send PM
|
Liberals view the world as the way they think it should be. Conservatives view the world the way it really is.
"Harry, I'm going to let you in on a little secret. Every day, once a day, give yourself a present. Don't plan it, don't wait for it, just let it happen. Could be a new shirt at the men's store, a catnap in your office chair, or two cups of good, hot, black coffee. Like this." -Dale Cooper
|
| 9. Wednesday, June 3, 2009 12:30 PM |
| Booth |
RE: From a Former Leftist |
Member Since 8/20/2006 Posts:4388
View Profile Send PM
|
Not sure how much I should trust people who use Ayn Rand to "deprogram" themselves.
|
| 10. Wednesday, June 3, 2009 12:33 PM |
| coolspringsj |
RE: From a Former Leftist |
Member Since 8/8/2007 Posts:3412
View Profile Send PM
|
Idealism vs. Realism - take your pick in this age old battle
"Harry, I'm going to let you in on a little secret. Every day, once a day, give yourself a present. Don't plan it, don't wait for it, just let it happen. Could be a new shirt at the men's store, a catnap in your office chair, or two cups of good, hot, black coffee. Like this." -Dale Cooper
|
| 11. Wednesday, June 3, 2009 12:49 PM |
| Booth |
RE: From a Former Leftist |
Member Since 8/20/2006 Posts:4388
View Profile Send PM
|
| QUOTE: Conservatives view the world the way it really is. | 6000 years old.
|
| 12. Wednesday, June 3, 2009 12:49 PM |
| bio_hazard |
RE: From a Former Leftist |
Member Since 7/7/2008 Posts:385
View Profile Send PM
|
I think the problem with it is that very few "liberals" actually believe all the things this author says she believed early on (even in Berkeley). I'm definitely left of center, (fwiw, on those graphs of social/economic ideology I came out in the middle of the liberal quandrant). You can be a liberal and have a 401k, dislike radical islam, not believe in 9/11 conspiracy theories... Also, the sort of implicit argument that if you don't believe ALL the things she says liberals stand for, then the only option is to go to the far right. I feel like she would self-destruct if she met someone with half an ounce of nuance to their political worldview.
She lost pretty much all resonance with me when she said she thought the democrats were getting to "rough and mean"(????), then decided she liked Savage and Hannity. Also the "family values" thing...
One thing that did strike a chord was on communist leaders. I didn't have much of an opinion on Castro (I wasn't alive for the cuban missle crisis- so cuba wasn't on my radar except for their cool cars and music). I did live/work for 6 months in pre-Chavez Venezuela. When he first came to power I was much more supportive of his regime and populist message, but I've definitely come to dislike him as he's clearly become just another a-hole dictator.
|
| 13. Wednesday, June 3, 2009 3:04 PM |
| nuart |
RE: From a Former Leftist |
Member Since 12/18/2005 Posts:7632
View Profile Send PM
|
Well, bio, she was writing with a modicum of intended humor so that could explain the broad strokes. As for being on the left and not believing 9/11 conspiracies, I agree with you that such lunacy is not exclusive to the left. I'm not even convinced that those who went bonifide wackidoo over 911 truthiness even believed in it so much as they were simply victims of viral Bush derangement syndrome of the era. However when in New York one Sunday, I happened onto a typical anti-war Sunday in Central Park, composed largely of leftie leftists. You can see much evidence of their proclivity to believe that "9/11 was an inside job" and to question just what happened to WTC-7 (or whichever bldg. it was) that so gripped the imagination of Rosey O'Donnell. Here are a few of my photo momentos of that day.
“Half a truth is often a great lie.” Ben Franklin
|
| 14. Wednesday, June 3, 2009 3:10 PM |
| coolspringsj |
RE: From a Former Leftist |
Member Since 8/8/2007 Posts:3412
View Profile Send PM
|
I didn't realize BOB was liberal.
"Harry, I'm going to let you in on a little secret. Every day, once a day, give yourself a present. Don't plan it, don't wait for it, just let it happen. Could be a new shirt at the men's store, a catnap in your office chair, or two cups of good, hot, black coffee. Like this." -Dale Cooper
|
| 15. Wednesday, June 3, 2009 5:26 PM |
| bio_hazard |
RE: From a Former Leftist |
Member Since 7/7/2008 Posts:385
View Profile Send PM
|
yup- those bumper stickers look just about right for the street vendors on Telegraph Ave in Berkeley. The cartoons and bumper stickers in Top Dog (a Berkeley institution that serves a darn fine weiner) are pretty much just libertarian (i.e. instead of tinfoil hat + bleeding heart, just tinfoil hat).
|
| 16. Wednesday, June 3, 2009 6:07 PM |
| Booth |
RE: From a Former Leftist |
Member Since 8/20/2006 Posts:4388
View Profile Send PM
|
Do people actually buy (those) bumper stickers?
|
| 17. Thursday, June 4, 2009 4:23 PM |
| bio_hazard |
RE: From a Former Leftist |
Member Since 7/7/2008 Posts:385
View Profile Send PM
|
at least in berkeley I think its mostly tourists who buy them. It's a cheap version of the "... all I got is this lousy t-shirt"
|
| 18. Thursday, June 4, 2009 6:51 PM |
| MayRay |
RE: From a Former Leftist |
Member Since 4/14/2008 Posts:505
View Profile Send PM
|
| QUOTE:Liberals view the world as the way they think it should be. Conservatives view the world the way it really is. |
Yeah, wanting to change the world is so lame.
|
| 19. Thursday, June 4, 2009 7:18 PM |
| MayRay |
RE: From a Former Leftist |
Member Since 4/14/2008 Posts:505
View Profile Send PM
|
So I had to check out this American Thinker website. What a bunch of silliness! Obama was blasted for wanting to pick Supreme Court justices with the quality of empathy (ridiculous!) and wanting to have some control over the big business who have their hands out for government money but want them to get lost after that. I mean, really, why should these businesses be accountable for the billions of dollars that our great grandkids will still be paying for? I don't believe in all liberal causes by any means. But I don't think there is anything wrong with the evolution of society as times change. I don't think that one can justify stagnation by calling it "traditional values". Slaveholders used to justify their cruelty by siting biblical passages by saying that being black was "the mark of Cain" and that they were supposed to be ruled over. Women had no personal rights because they weren't "smart enough" to make decisions. Introduction of new ideas and ideals doesn't taint society. The beauty of this country is that we have the right to choose, to vote for the causes that we all find important. This is one of the founding principles of the United States. I think the conservatives are just salty that they aren't the majority anymore.
|
| 20. Friday, June 5, 2009 9:26 AM |
| MayRay |
RE: From a Former Leftist |
Member Since 4/14/2008 Posts:505
View Profile Send PM
|
I often wonder how much thought conservatives give to traditional values that used to make up the moral fabric of our society 1. Interracial marriages were illegal 2. In cases of divorce, custody of the children was always awarded to the father 3. Oral and anal sex were punishable offenses 4. Women were not allowed to inherit or purchase property 5. Juries were made up of white males only 6. Black men would be hung for sleeping with white women, whereas white men were free to use and abuse black women 7. Blacks were expected to use different restrooms and water fountains, routinely denied service at public establishments, not allowed to attend certain public schools, and expected to give up seats on public transportation under the guise of "separate but equal" 8. Universities were open only to white males 9. The vote was reserved for white males 10. Gay clubs were raided by the police and patrons were rounded up and hauled to jail 11. The only careers that women were free to pursue would be that of a teacher or nurse These notions seem so antiquated in society today. I think the changes have been good. However, I am curious to hear from the conservatives here. Would our country be a better place if these laws were repealed and we returned to our more traditional values? Is a country made stronger by excluding and punishing certain members who don't fit what a certain sector thinks is right? Who has the right to be the morality police anyways? Jesus said "Let he who is without sin cast the first stone." He went out of his way to minister to and care for prostitutes and tax collectors, which were the dregs of society in his time. So I think the next time a conservative is standing there with a rock in their hand, perhaps they should give some thought to what the true message of the Bible is. God loves everyone, in spite of their shortcomings.
|
| 21. Friday, June 5, 2009 3:44 PM |
| nuart |
RE: From a Former Leftist |
Member Since 12/18/2005 Posts:7632
View Profile Send PM
|
| QUOTE: I often wonder how much thought conservatives give to traditional values that used to make up the moral fabric of our society 1. Interracial marriages were illegal 2. In cases of divorce, custody of the children was always awarded to the father 3. Oral and anal sex were punishable offenses 4. Women were not allowed to inherit or purchase property 5. Juries were made up of white males only 6. Black men would be hung for sleeping with white women, whereas white men were free to use and abuse black women 7. Blacks were expected to use different restrooms and water fountains, routinely denied service at public establishments, not allowed to attend certain public schools, and expected to give up seats on public transportation under the guise of "separate but equal" 8. Universities were open only to white males 9. The vote was reserved for white males 10. Gay clubs were raided by the police and patrons were rounded up and hauled to jail 11. The only careers that women were free to pursue would be that of a teacher or nurse These notions seem so antiquated in society today. I think the changes have been good. However, I am curious to hear from the conservatives here. Would our country be a better place if these laws were repealed and we returned to our more traditional values? Is a country made stronger by excluding and punishing certain members who don't fit what a certain sector thinks is right? Who has the right to be the morality police anyways? Jesus said "Let he who is without sin cast the first stone." He went out of his way to minister to and care for prostitutes and tax collectors, which were the dregs of society in his time. So I think the next time a conservative is standing there with a rock in their hand, perhaps they should give some thought to what the true message of the Bible is. God loves everyone, in spite of their shortcomings. |
1. Where were interracial marriages illegal? I'm not denying that in a few states at certain points in US history, black and white marriages were illegal. But there was never a mainstream religious movement that endorsed that anomoly. So let us not assume that the laws (which I believe you will have to Google to find out the details of the tiresome mantra) were the Law of the USA and part of the "traditional America" of conservatives. 2. What???? Where? Why? When? 3. Once again you cite some odd little local injunctions with no context. If you now Google the details, see if you can find out how often these laws were enforced. 4. Now we're going back to when? A millenium or so? Ancient Greece? Surely not Rome. Nor post-Magna Carta England.
5. That's pretty true. I saw "12 Angry Men" too. But up until what time? And just how much negative 'conservative' reaction was there? 6. And this you call a "traditional value?" Something conservatives of the nation supported?!
7. Yes. True in southern US states into the 20th century whereas many conservatives throughout the nation were against this holdover attitude that came from the chaos and racism of slavery. Recall that Charlton (conservative) Heston among many others was one who actively protested this moral outrage.
8. Some universities were exclusively male like Princeton. As some were exclusively female like Sarah Lawrence. But then it changed. And almost every university is open to men and women. There are still universities that are just for African-Americans though I think Howard accepts a handful of students of other races now.
9. This probably still goes on. I know there were raids of gay bathhouses during the height of the AIDS era in the 80s in SF and LA. Were they raided because gay men were having sex? Or was there something else going on? 10. You give no timeline or place and left out secretary. And housewifery! Midwivery and wet nurse too. Granted there are more women in careers that had traditionally been exclusively a man's domain up until the mid-20th century USA. But it's just not true that women were not 'free' to struggle through those barriers. Discouraged? Sure. More difficult than for a man? Yup. There are too many examples otherwise to try to make the assertion that women couldn't pursue other careers.
Anyway, May, we're dealing with a massive topic here when discussing "traditional" and conservative values versus liberal values. A society is a living organism. Every seeming small societal change has a ripple effect sometimes unanticipated. One small example -- the coarsening of the culture. Let's take TV and film. Time was (like until the late 60s) when you wouldn't hear the words "damn" or any minor expletive. Little by little, the loosening up of the language. Lenny Bruce does a whole number on forbidden words before George Carlin's act. We all congratulate ourselves for our maturity. Hey, they're just words. Freedom of speech. And now, you can find yourself walking the aisles of a supermarket listening to teenagers "F" wording this and "F" wording that with not a sign of embarrassment. It's common parlance. Good thing, bad thing, neutral? Don't take this as my case for status quo for time immemorial. I'm only using it as a small example of a path of something that seems innocuous but leads to a change in respect, civility and manners.
Conservatives (at least this one) do not bolt against every change. I think it's more about considering more carefully the consequences of those items we think have made our society a strong and successful one. And I do not draw my conclusions as a result of anything Jesus did or said. I think Christianity had served the nation well but I myself am not a Christian. Susan PS May, I forgot to mention I commend you for checking out the American Thinker website. They are not all class A writers over there but there are an awful lot of goodies. I still think the creme de la creme of news writing comes from the WSJ though.
“Half a truth is often a great lie.” Ben Franklin
|
| 22. Friday, June 5, 2009 6:20 PM |
| MayRay |
RE: From a Former Leftist |
Member Since 4/14/2008 Posts:505
View Profile Send PM
|
The US didn't lift the official ban on interacial marriages until 1965, before that it was on a state to state basis It was a common law practice in the late 1800's that the father was awarded custody of children In 1855, the University of Iowa was the first state university to open its doors on a equal basis to men and women. The United States didn't officially strike down all sodomy laws until 2003. I thoroughly agree with you on the whole potty mouth thing. I get tired of the f bomb being dropped about everything. I think television is more obscenity than entertainment. I also find it discouraging that alot of parents today seem to let the television raise their children. I should have put up more sitations for my claims on my earlier post. I'm not the type of person to just randomly spout out stuff. I'm also not of the belief that the Democratic party is the party of the common man. I think that 99% of politicians are out of touch with the people they represent. For the record, I am firmly against gun control. Disarming the people has always been the first step to a fascist regime. I think the US should stay out of the Middle East but I have nothing but the utmost respect for the men and women who lay down their lives to preserve the freedoms that we all hold dear. I also have alot of admiration for individuals who stick to their guns even when the majority is against them. I give you the utmost props Nuart. Concerning property rights for women- Okay most of my facts are based on laws enacted here in my great state of Iowa. The Iowa Code of 1851 gave married women property rights. I have been reading alot of Jane Austen novels lately so I may have been confusing things a bit. But I imagine that if it was a common practice in England that only men could inherit that it would have been similar here. I didn't really mean to say racism was a conservative value. That was wrong of me. I just seem to equate Southerners with conservatism. I also am not saying that all Southerners are or were racists before anyone gets their panties in a bind. I'm just saying that the laws that were made to protect people against these atrocious acts were an important part of our nation's history.
|
| 23. Friday, June 5, 2009 8:52 PM |
| nuart |
RE: From a Former Leftist |
Member Since 12/18/2005 Posts:7632
View Profile Send PM
|
Interesting story re/the Loving v. Virginia case, May. Thanks for bringing up the subject because I was truly shocked that this was such recent history. Check it out ! Susan
“Half a truth is often a great lie.” Ben Franklin
|
| 24. Saturday, June 6, 2009 5:12 AM |
| 12rainbow |
RE: From a Former Leftist |
Member Since 12/19/2005 Posts:4953
View Profile Send PM
|
If I recall the voting percentages,it looked about 50/50. I don't think anyone was ever a majority or minority.
http://www-personal.umich.edu/~mejn/election/2008/
The left and right are flip sides of the same bullheaded coin, and the machine cranks out the same control freak leaders every election no matter which side "wins." Everyone loses whenever the system has too much control.
I used to be left-leaning, myself and then I came to realize that I valued freedom and couldn't trust politicians.
|
| 25. Saturday, June 6, 2009 6:18 AM |
| MayRay |
RE: From a Former Leftist |
Member Since 4/14/2008 Posts:505
View Profile Send PM
|
Pretty crazy huh? I don't think the government has any right to tell people who they can love and spend the rest of their lives with. I think one day the public will see the opposition to gay marriage to be on par with the ban on interracial marriage. I believe when it comes to election time, voting is a matter of choosing the lesser of the two evils. My hope is that the citizens of this country will continue to become more politically aware and perhaps we will get some candidates out there that really represent.
|
|
New Topic |
Post Reply
|
Page 1 of 2 ::
<< |
1 | 2 |
>>
|
|
Politics
> From a Former Leftist
|
| Users viewing this Topic (1) |
| 1 Guest |
Powered by JorkelBB 2006 (Version 1.0b)
|
|
|